THE HUMAN STORY November 1, 2009
Posted by wmmbb in Humankind/Planet Earth.trackback
The environmental crisis will continue unabated unless appropriate action is taken, and appropriate action will not be taken until tunnel vision of nationality rather than global society is swept away.
How then to account for what has happened, and what is required? David Korten has an alternative narrative of the human experience on planet Earth. He writes,(via Common Dreams) originally in Yes Magazine:
For the past 5,000 years, we humans have been living in a cultural trance of our own making that alienates us from the land, our true nature, and our place in the cosmos.
So who are we humans? From where did we come? And for what purpose? Here is how I understand the big story based on the data of science, the wisdom of indigenous peoples, and the teachings of Jesus and other mystics.
Hundreds of thousands of years ago, the Great Integral Spirit that expresses itself through what we know as creation embarked on a bold and risky experiment in reflective consciousness: bringing forth a species able to step back and to reflect on creation in awe and wonder and to participate as a conscious co-creator in the continued creative unfolding. We humans are that species.
Our reflective consciousness gives us the capacity to choose our future with conscious collective intent. It was a risky experiment, however, because the capacity for self-awareness gives us an ego that can run out of control if it forgets it exists only as part of a larger whole.
In our earliest days, we humans raised our children collectively in the clan, tribe, or village, initiating them to the ways of life and the need to care for our Earth Mother as she in turn cares for us.
Over millennia, as our human consciousness was awakening and our capacities for self-direction grew, we learned to communicate through speech, master fire, domesticate plants and animals, and construct houses of skins, wood, stone, and dried mud. We developed the arts of pottery, painting, weaving, and carving. We undertook vast continental and transcontinental migrations to populate the planet and adapted to vastly different physical topographies and climates. We created complex languages and social codes that allowed for life in larger communities.
Then, some 5,000 years ago, something began to go terribly wrong. We turned from the ways of Earth Community and embraced the ways of Empire. It was a time of separation and forgetting. Community, partnership, and the celebration of life gave way to individualism, domination, and violence.
The few expropriated the wealth of the many. The masculine drove out the feminine. We continued to worship the Sky Father, but turned against our Earth Mother. We came to value the power to kill and destroy more highly than the ability to create and nurture life. Conquest became the measure of greatness. Economies came to be based on servitude and eventually money became the prime arbiter of human relationships.
Consider the dynamics inherent in a dominator system. With a few on the top and the many on the bottom, everyone is placed in competition with everyone else for the favored positions and the bonds of caring and sharing are broken. The creative energy of the species is redirected from securing the well-being of the tribe to advancing the technological instruments of war and the social instruments of domination.
The winners expropriate the available resources to maintain the system of domination. Positions of power are too often claimed by the most ruthless and psychologically damaged members of society. And so it has been for 5,000 years
If this discussion of Empire sounds familiar, it is for good reason. The kings and emperors have been replaced by corporate CEOs and hedge fund managers, but we are still living in the Era of Empire—and the basic dynamics still hold.
In the past 100 years, we humans have achieved technological mastery beyond the imagination of previous generations. Yet, lacking in the wisdom of place and community that is the heritage of indigenous peoples, the cultures we call mainstream have lost their way—forgetting what it means to be human and denying our connection to the web of planetary life. The time has come to rediscover our humanity and bring ourselves back into balance with our living Earth Mother. Creation has presented us with our final examination to determine whether we are a species worthy of survival. We must not, need not, fail.
His thesis is arresting as it is radical. He argues that to have peace, a practical option for rehumanized human beings, it is necessary to have a peace economy. His premise:
I start with a basic truth. A persistent pattern of violence against people, community, and nature is inherent in the institutional structure of our existing economy.
Is this the truth? Since institutional structures are based on culture and stories about human nature, we need to ask the question, what is the truth about human nature? Are we the rapacious, egotistical, competitive beings that our society has cast us in the role of being?
(I was tired when I posted this, but have been thinking in a general way about David Korten said. Any statements made here by me require further qualification. David Korten’s views challenge mine, and mine to some degree challenge his, so I think anyway they are worth considering.)

[...] THE HUMAN STORY « DUCKPOND [...]
I let this through since it deals with emotional abuse, a form of violence which would be good to greatly reduce, if not eliminate.
Sounds perfectly sound to me, wmmbb. Love is the most excellent way. You ask: “Are we the rapacious, egotistical, competitive beings that our society has cast us in the role of being?” I’m afraid we are. Can you imagine what children would become if left to their own devices or unprotected? In fact, we are seeing this sad scene being played out in cities and villages around the world. Watch children closely. If you don’t instill within them a sense of right and wrong and protect them, they will often go right ahead repeatedly doing what is wrong as means for protection and survival.
Even when taught well, re-enforcement is essential by not only the parents but society at large. There has been a lapse of this in our most modern times and this is what the article seems to address, the increasing lack of community and the substitution of this lack with merely things. “Love covers a multitude of faults.” But what we are experiencing largely in the economic systems of the world is an exploitation of weakness and a gamming of the system whether legal or not. Many times things ae legal, but unethical, yet we go forth with them anyway. In fact, this is the job largely of many lawyers: to skate the thin line of legality.
What is unfortunate is that young people are largely living within these system (there is another one that Jesus spoke of that is more in line with the words here) where at least in times past there seemed to have been more of a barrier for them between and such harsh realities. It would be better yet if we dealt with these realities honestly and sought to eliminate them among ourselves. They don’t even work wholly for adults. I remember as a very young people trying to rationalize how to do business ethically. Even to this day with dealing with small building contractors, it is a constant question for me. We are all trying to be profitable. I ALWAYS consider others.
Considering again your question about human nature, I taught as a substitute teacher for many years in graduate school and it was a great experience in human behavior. Most of these kids had parents who more or less really cared about them. But the basic goodness in children cannot be denied also. They are generally looking for love that which is so needed to exist properly in the world and enables growth of all kind. “Love conquers all.”
Children have another nature as well. You know well that I am big believer in the message of Jesus and am a huge proponent of his words. It was he who said, “Truly, I say to you, unless you turn and become like children, you will never enter the kingdom of heaven. (This is for me God’s way of doing things through love in deferring to others and forgetting wrongs done to them.) Whoever humbles himself like this child is the greatest in the kingdom of heaven.” The honesty and trust of children are also remarkable. We are forever coming to the knowledge of the truth.
Thanks, wmmbb, for this post. I may not have found these words, yours and his, in this way otherwise. Words matter.
Thanks for the comment Judith. I will get around to a fuller response in due course.
You raise some issues that I had not entered into my thinking, for example. the questions of right and wrong, and the need to protect children. I think you are right about the need for the community to protect children. On reflection, even though my parents were very concerned about our safety, I am amazed with what they allowed us to do as young children. We used to swim in the river for example, which might have been a dangerous environment, especially when in flood. Then they entrusted us to the tender mercies of others at teachers, who they presumed knew better, but on reflection it seems to me they were often not competent. Just to clarify this more, I went to a boarding school from six years of age to about ten or eleven.
Organizations are inherently systemic, often in our society based on mechanistic models, rather that human expression. Much of our behavior is indoctrinated rather than based on self awareness – I think it is true for me. For example violence is a robust process in the dynamic of the interaction and within the person.
A person, but particularly a child who witnesses violence, can be subtly shifted in their internal orientation -that my introspection. Yet parents, for example, allow children to watch violent television. One of my deepest regrets is that when someone was talking to me about violence, I did my usual thing and blustered and did not address the issue as I should have. I might have been about to say something that was helpful. It is a situation that creates a tragedy for people. Our task as human beings is to be competent at basic levels.