jump to navigation

THREE FALLACIES TOO MANY October 22, 2009

Posted by wmmbb in CENTRAL ASIA, Humankind/Planet Earth.
trackback

The thought occurs:  Johann Hari, who writes for The Independent, must be a smart bloke. Pay that as a strike in the win/lose game between journalists and bloggers, but equally pay that as a strike in the win/win game- as Mark Antony said at the funeral. . .

While I was attempting to be hardboiled, as you do, I had an earlier appreciation when reading Johann Hari’s piece on Gore Vidal. I thought that he had got to the guts, or should that be essence, of things. Similarly he achieves the same result, in my humble opinion, with his article on Afghanistan.

Read the article, but Johan Hari also identifies three false arguments for staying the course of violence and inflection of suffering on Afghanistan, so we can imagine ourselves to free of the burden of our humanity and conscience, and simultaneously providing succour to the other purveyors of violence, al Qaeda, in their cave, or around their kitchen table wherever that might be.

Phew! Here are the fallacies in point form:

  • Argument One: We need to deprive al-Qa’ida of military bases in Afghanistan, or they will use them to plot attacks against us, and we will face 9/11 redux.
  • Argument Two: By staying, we are significantly improving Afghan human rights, especially for women.
  • Argument Three: If we withdraw, it will be a great victory for al-Qa’ida. Re-energised, they will surge out across the world.

Oh, and by the way, did you not notice there is a superordinate fallacy, we might not want to notice that justice is not served by violence. Violence is the language and mode of the strong who seek domination to create a world in their image. Truth might be won by persuasion.

Let me speculate, in part because of the ubiquity of global communication, not least the global climate crisis, humanity has reached the end point for the game of politics and iniquity based on violence. If the case, the end game invites a choice between alternatives.

I have just noticed that Barry McQuire reframing his old song, also postdated it:

ELSEWHERE:

It is pleasing, and a very positive development, to see that Rachel Maddow is calling out the “Keep America Safe” folks – as if we only have to think about our own backyards.

Our narrative, to offer human dignity, has to include and respect all the peoples and cultures of the Globe.

(Perhaps it might be better represented as the Geoid)

At Counter Punch, Liaquat Al Khan, notes the sequential destruction of Muslim Nations, now including in the chain reaction Pakistan. I concede the observation, but wonder why Pakistan did not develop as a India into a multi-cultural nation? I suspect the answer is as simple as monoculture never create biodiversity, which presupposes tolerance and cohabitation.

Rick Chamberlin, at Common Dreams, incisively reinterprets Martin Luther King (and Barack Obama) in the context and the key of coherence.

About these ads

Comments»

1. Dylan Smith - October 24, 2009

Brave New Films is a new media, non-profit organization at the forefront of using video to amplify, create, and tell stories that inform, change attitudes, and motivate people to take action. Our campaigns range from health care reform to corporate accountability to the war in Afghanistan. See http://bravenewfilms.org for more about us.

We noticed you have run our content or linked to us in the past and we invite you to continue to be an active part of our campaigns. Take a look at the snapshot below for some of our recent work and let me know what interests you.

Sick for Profit exposes the personal indulgences of health care executives while denying coverage to patients. These failures of the American health care system demonstrate the urgent need for reform. We’ve exposed three of the major insurance companies to date. http://sickforprofit.com/

Rethink Afghanistan, a six part documentary released throughout the year addressing the issues of the war in Afghanistan. See all segments on the site. http://rethinkafghanistan.com/

Senator Sanders Unfiltered, a weekly five minute show with independent Sen. Bernie Sanders answering challenging video questions submitted from constituents – unfiltered and direct to you. http://sandersunfiltered.com/

Please let me know what content interests you and the Brave New Films Distribution team will add you to our email notification list. (Your email will not be shared and you will only get the content that you want to receive.)

Contact:
dylansmith [at] bravenewfilms.org


Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s

Follow

Get every new post delivered to your Inbox.

Join 40 other followers

%d bloggers like this: